Leonardo Da Vinci’s breathing system

Leonardo Da Vinci’s breathing system 2017-01-15T18:09:16+00:00

header_da_vinci

Most of us are familiar with Leonardo Da Vinci  as being a renowned artist who painted masterpieces such as the Mona Lisa and the Last Supper.

artwork

However, Leonardo Da Vinci, who lived about 500 years ago, was much more than an artist. He was also a great thinker and fortunately for us, he noted many of his thoughts on sheets of paper. Even though they are over 500 years old, many thousands of these sheets of paper have survived in a good condition. Shown below is one such sheet.

sample_mechanical_atlanticus_0026r

The notes of Leonardo Da Vinci show that he had a very wide area of interest. For an example, the drawing below shows his idea for an helicopter, 500 years before modern helicopters were invented !

heli_manu_B_83v_leotex

Quite a few of his ideas were for war machines. This one shows special canon balls that open up to let loose multiple smaller canon balls. Notice how, even though they are “engineering” drawings, they are still artistically beautiful as well.

canon_atlanticus_0033r_leotex

Leonardo was also very interested in the human body and did many anatomical studies on human and ox bodies..

heartlung_windsor_rl1910v

However, as an anaesthetist, what I find very fascinating is Leonardo Da Vinci’s attempts to design a way for man to breath underwater. For an example, his note books contain these two drawings showing designs of an underwater breathing system. In this design, the submerged diver wears a mask that is connected to a long tube..

single_tubes_at_26r_1069r

The long breathing tube is fixed to a disc which floats on the water. The floating disc keeps one end of the tube exposed to the atmosphere. The diver now simply breathes in and out through this tube.

underwater_single_tubes

Of course, with our modern understanding of breathing systems, we know that this single tube breathing system would not work. Because of the long tube, the oxygen from the atmosphere wouldn’t reach the diver and nor would the carbon dioxide he produces reach the end of the tube to be expelled out. The diver would suffer what we know today as “re breathing”. He would soon die of hypoxia and hypercarbia. So it seems that Leonardo had designed his breathing system wrong.

insp_expi_single_tube

Or did he actually realise his mistake ? We will have to do some detective work to find out. Among the many thousand note pages, we find this one which shows another underwater breathing system.

full_arun_24v

If you look closely, you will note that this underwater breathing system has two tubes, rather than the single tube that you saw previously.

waves_arun_24v

With this design, if the inspiratory gases go into the diver through one tube and the expiratory gases go out through the other tube, re breathing would not occur.

logic_two_tubes_arun_24v

However, for it to work as described above, there has to be a way to make sure that inspiration always occurs through only one tube and that expiration always occurs through the other tube. Without such a mechanism, as shown below, re breathing would happen in both tubes and the diver would die.

no_valve_two_tubes_arun_24v

Below is the note page with the double tube breathing system. Perhaps in the text next to the diagram, he has mentioned such a mechanism?  Unfortunately the text only  mentions how the system is constructed and does not mention any mechanism to separate inspiration and expiration pathways. For an example, he mentions how to make the tubes rigid enough to prevent it collapsing due to water pressure, while still providing some flexibility. But there is no mention of inspiration and expiration happening in different tubes.

text_italian

We will therefore have to do some detective work to see if Leonardo had thought of a mechanism to separate the inspiratory and expiratory pathways in the breathing system. If you go through the other hundreds of pages of his notebooks, you will find the interesting page shown below. Don’t worry if you can’t see things too clearly. I will explain it all in a bit more detail soon.

portion_at_647v

We can see below that the new page has details of the two tube diving breathing system. Historians have given each page of Leonardo’s note books a unique page number. The page showing the two tube breathing system we first saw has the number 24v. The new page I have introduced you to has the number 647v.  You can see in the image below, that in page 647v, he has drawn the diving mask (red arrow) and the float (green arrow). So, we can safely say that page 647v is referring to the same breathing system as shown in page 24v.

linkage

Let us look at the mask on page 647v a bit more closely. You can see that there is a small drawing near the mask (green arrow).

mask_side_highlight_647v

The small diagram seems to show a detailed cross section of where the tubes are attached in the larger diagram next to it. And in this cross section, if you look closely, you can see one way valves ! (Do not worry if you are not convinced,  as I will show you better diagrams later). These one way valves will ensure that inspiration always occurs from one tube (green) and that expiration will always occur from the other tube (red). This is probably the oldest document that shows valves being used in a breathing system. Isn’t it amazing that this was done 500 years ago ! As mentioned before, do not worry if you are not yet convinced that the diagram shows valves. I will show you better material shortly.

plain_mask_detail_647v

As mentioned before, some of you may doubt that the above diagram shows one way valves. Well, if you are such person, fortunately for you, Leonardo Da Vinci has drawn even more one way valve designs ! The arrow in the image below shows another set of valves drawn on the same page as the mask. I will show more details of it in the image that follows this one.

conical_highlight

Here is a close up of the one way valves shown above. The valves consist of two flaps, each of which open only in one direction.

conical_only_flaps

During inspiration (green arrows), the green coloured flap will open and the red coloured flap will close. During expiration (red arrows), the green flap will close and the red one will open. For clarity, in the drawing, Leonardo has shown both valves open, whereas in reality, only one would be open at a given time. The two conical tubes ( like horns) would have been connected to the inspiratory and expiratory tubing going to the surface of the water. With these diagrams of one way valves, I hope you are convinced that Leonardo Da Vinci designed his breathing system to have separate inspiratory and expiratory tubing.

conical_mask_647v

Page 647v has some more interesting objects drawn by Leonardo Da Vinci. I am not very sure what they represent and would welcome your thoughts on them. I think image A is another diving mask with the one way valves (B) located in the bulge at the top (image A, black arrow). Images C,D and E are also probably more one way valve systems connected to tubing. Please let me know, via the contact page, if you have any other ideas about these.

mytery_objects_647v

Leonardo was quite secretive about his underwater devices because he feared that they might be used for dangerous activities. For an example, divers at that time (and even in the present) could be used by the military to destroy ships. Perhaps for this reason, he has written extremely little on how the breathing system works. One has to, like we have done so far, use the images to guess how things work. However, with some more detective work, we can find some text where Leonardo mentions how the one way valves work. We again go to page 647v, which shows the diving mask. In this page, there is a small diagram (green arrow) that is interesting. I will show it in more detail later. I will show you how this little diagram will lead us to Leonardo’s textual description of his breathing system.

mask_rotor_highlight_647v

In the enlarged image below, you see two openings (red arrows) with one way valves. One of the valves is quite clearly seen (green).

door_recognition_647v

Now if we further search the notes of Leonardo, we find this intriguing page. It has a diagram with similar valve flaps to those seen above. I will show further comparisons in the images that follow this one.

24_reverse_valve_boxx

You can see, how the diagram with one way valves on this new page (red arrow)  is similar to the valve diagram we saw on the page showing the diving mask breathing system (green arrow). We can therefore say that the diagram on the new page (red arrow) is that of a breathing system.

24_reverse_valvebox

 

Here is a close up of both diagrams to help you compare them.

 

grey_door_comparisonx

Just in case you find the comparison difficult, I have tried to colour the images to help you.

colour_door_comparisonx

Fortunately, the text written by Leonardo that accompanies the drawing of the one way breathing valves explains how the valves work. I will translate it for you soon !

valve_box_originaltext_plain

For those who can read Italian, here is a clearer version of the text.

italian_vavle_box

I will shortly give the English translation of the above text. Please note that in Leonardo’s time, people did not know about oxygen or carbon dioxide. Instead, ventilation was considered necessary to “cool” the body. So when Leonardo refers to “cold air”, you can think of this as oxygen which “cools” the body. Similarly, when Leonardo talks about “hot air”, think of it as meaning carbon dioxide carrying heat away from the body. The English translation that I will show you is the best I have so far, based on feedback from Italian visitors to this website. If you can read Italian and can improve this translation, please let me know your suggestions. So finally, here is his text !

english_valve_box_translation

Now here is something very interesting about the  image we have have been discussing so far. As mentioned before, these diagrams are drawn on paper sheets. Let us wonder what is there on the other side of this paper.

flip_over_24v_question

On the other side of the page is our familiar two tube diving apparatus !

flip_over_24v_answer

Well I hope you are convinced that Leonardo Da Vinci was not only an artist ! It is possible that he was the first person to have designed a breathing system using valves in order to prevent re breathing. All this was 500 years ago ! Next time you use an anaesthesia breathing system using valves, remember Leonardo Da Vinci thought of it first.

modern_breathingsystem

I am not the first person to suggest the connection between Leonardo and the breathing system with one way valves, but collecting all the above information took me nearly two years, mainly because there is so little information about it on the web. That is why I thought I should share this fascinating material with all of you. Please ask your friends to visit this page. Also, I am not a professional historian, so I truly welcome any further information you can give me. Thank you and breath well.

mona_lisa_mask